Merge bitcoin/bitcoin#30828: interfaces: #30697 follow ups

8466329127 chain: simplify `deleteRwSettings` code and improve it's doc (ismaelsadeeq)
f8d91f49c7 chain: dont check for null settings value in `overwriteRwSetting` (ismaelsadeeq)
df601993f2 chain: ensure `updateRwSetting` doesn't update to a null settings (ismaelsadeeq)
c8e2eeeffb chain: uniformly use `SettingsAction` enum in settings methods (ismaelsadeeq)
1e9e735670 chain: move new settings safely in `overwriteRwSetting` (ismaelsadeeq)
1c409004c8 test: remove wallet context from `write_wallet_settings_concurrently` (ismaelsadeeq)

Pull request description:

  This PR addresses the remaining review comments from #30697

  1. Disallowed overwriting settings values with a `null` value.
  2. Uniformly used the `SettingsAction` enum in all settings methods instead of a boolean parameter.
  3. Updated `overwriteRwSetting` to receive the `common::SettingsValue` parameter by value, enabling it to be moved safely.
  4. Removed wallet context from the `write_wallet_settings_concurrently` unit test, as it is not needed.

ACKs for top commit:
  achow101:
    ACK 8466329127
  ryanofsky:
    Code review ACK 8466329127. Looks good, thanks for taking suggestions and applying them to the right commits. Only changes since last review were documentation improvements and simplifying delete method.
  furszy:
    Code review ACK 8466329127

Tree-SHA512: baf2f59ed5aac4a4bda0c84fb6554a466a40d1f7b52b61dc2ff293d83ae60e82b925b7003237b633fecb65eba3a4c108e69166046895d1295809fbe0de67b052

src/interfaces/chain.h

@@ -356,15 +356,22 @@ public:
     virtual common::SettingsValue getRwSetting(const std::string& name) = 0;
 
     //! Updates a setting in <datadir>/settings.json.
+    //! Null can be passed to erase the setting. There is intentionally no
+    //! support for writing null values to settings.json.
     //! Depending on the action returned by the update function, this will either
     //! update the setting in memory or write the updated settings to disk.
     virtual bool updateRwSetting(const std::string& name, const SettingsUpdate& update_function) = 0;
 
     //! Replace a setting in <datadir>/settings.json with a new value.
-    virtual bool overwriteRwSetting(const std::string& name, common::SettingsValue& value, bool write = true) = 0;
+    //! Null can be passed to erase the setting.
+    //! This method provides a simpler alternative to updateRwSetting when
+    //! atomically reading and updating the setting is not required.
+    virtual bool overwriteRwSetting(const std::string& name, common::SettingsValue value, SettingsAction action = SettingsAction::WRITE) = 0;
 
     //! Delete a given setting in <datadir>/settings.json.
-    virtual bool deleteRwSettings(const std::string& name, bool write = true) = 0;
+    //! This method provides a simpler alternative to overwriteRwSetting when
+    //! erasing a setting, for ease of use and readability.
+    virtual bool deleteRwSettings(const std::string& name, SettingsAction action = SettingsAction::WRITE) = 0;
 
     //! Synchronously send transactionAddedToMempool notifications about all
     //! current mempool transactions to the specified handler and return after

src/node/interfaces.cpp

@@ -820,29 +820,29 @@ public:
     {
         std::optional<interfaces::SettingsAction> action;
         args().LockSettings([&](common::Settings& settings) {
-            auto* ptr_value = common::FindKey(settings.rw_settings, name);
+            if (auto* value = common::FindKey(settings.rw_settings, name)) {
-            // Create value if it doesn't exist
+                action = update_settings_func(*value);
-            auto& value = ptr_value ? *ptr_value : settings.rw_settings[name];
+                if (value->isNull()) settings.rw_settings.erase(name);
-            action = update_settings_func(value);
+            } else {
+                UniValue new_value;
+                action = update_settings_func(new_value);
+                if (!new_value.isNull()) settings.rw_settings[name] = std::move(new_value);
+            }
         });
         if (!action) return false;
         // Now dump value to disk if requested
-        return *action == interfaces::SettingsAction::SKIP_WRITE || args().WriteSettingsFile();
+        return *action != interfaces::SettingsAction::WRITE || args().WriteSettingsFile();
     }
-    bool overwriteRwSetting(const std::string& name, common::SettingsValue& value, bool write) override
+    bool overwriteRwSetting(const std::string& name, common::SettingsValue value, interfaces::SettingsAction action) override
     {
-        if (value.isNull()) return deleteRwSettings(name, write);
         return updateRwSetting(name, [&](common::SettingsValue& settings) {
             settings = std::move(value);
-            return write ? interfaces::SettingsAction::WRITE : interfaces::SettingsAction::SKIP_WRITE;
+            return action;
         });
     }
-    bool deleteRwSettings(const std::string& name, bool write) override
+    bool deleteRwSettings(const std::string& name, interfaces::SettingsAction action) override
     {
-        args().LockSettings([&](common::Settings& settings) {
+        return overwriteRwSetting(name, {}, action);
-            settings.rw_settings.erase(name);
-        });
-        return !write || args().WriteSettingsFile();
     }
     void requestMempoolTransactions(Notifications& notifications) override
     {

src/wallet/load.cpp

@@ -69,7 +69,7 @@ bool VerifyWallets(WalletContext& context)
             // Pass write=false because no need to write file and probably
             // better not to. If unnamed wallet needs to be added next startup
             // and the setting is empty, this code will just run again.
-            chain.overwriteRwSetting("wallet", wallets, /*write=*/false);
+            chain.overwriteRwSetting("wallet", std::move(wallets), interfaces::SettingsAction::SKIP_WRITE);
         }
     }
 

src/wallet/test/wallet_tests.cpp

@@ -334,12 +334,11 @@ BOOST_FIXTURE_TEST_CASE(importwallet_rescan, TestChain100Setup)
 // concurrently, ensuring no race conditions occur during either process.
 BOOST_FIXTURE_TEST_CASE(write_wallet_settings_concurrently, TestingSetup)
 {
-    WalletContext context;
+    auto chain = m_node.chain.get();
-    context.chain = m_node.chain.get();
     const auto NUM_WALLETS{5};
 
     // Since we're counting the number of wallets, ensure we start without any.
-    BOOST_REQUIRE(context.chain->getRwSetting("wallet").isNull());
+    BOOST_REQUIRE(chain->getRwSetting("wallet").isNull());
 
     const auto& check_concurrent_wallet = [&](const auto& settings_function, int num_expected_wallets) {
         std::vector<std::thread> threads;
@@ -347,19 +346,19 @@ BOOST_FIXTURE_TEST_CASE(write_wallet_settings_concurrently, TestingSetup)
         for (auto i{0}; i < NUM_WALLETS; ++i) threads.emplace_back(settings_function, i);
         for (auto& t : threads) t.join();
 
-        auto wallets = context.chain->getRwSetting("wallet");
+        auto wallets = chain->getRwSetting("wallet");
         BOOST_CHECK_EQUAL(wallets.getValues().size(), num_expected_wallets);
     };
 
     // Add NUM_WALLETS wallets concurrently, ensure we end up with NUM_WALLETS stored.
-    check_concurrent_wallet([&context](int i) {
+    check_concurrent_wallet([&chain](int i) {
-        Assert(AddWalletSetting(*context.chain, strprintf("wallet_%d", i)));
+        Assert(AddWalletSetting(*chain, strprintf("wallet_%d", i)));
     },
                             /*num_expected_wallets=*/NUM_WALLETS);
 
     // Remove NUM_WALLETS wallets concurrently, ensure we end up with 0 wallets.
-    check_concurrent_wallet([&context](int i) {
+    check_concurrent_wallet([&chain](int i) {
-        Assert(RemoveWalletSetting(*context.chain, strprintf("wallet_%d", i)));
+        Assert(RemoveWalletSetting(*chain, strprintf("wallet_%d", i)));
     },
                             /*num_expected_wallets=*/0);
 }